Argyll and the Isles appeals to congregations to combat ‘perilous’ budget deficit

Want to read more?

We value our content  and access to our full site is  only available on subscription. Your subscription entitles you to 7-day-a-week access to our website, plus a full digital copy of that week’s paper to read on your pc/mac or mobile device In addition your subscription includes access to digital archive copies from 2006 onwards

Already a subscriber?


Subscribe Now

Argyll and the Isles Diocese, which has existed since 1878, is under threat of running out of money and assets in nine years if the diocese’s current deficit of nearly £90,000 a year is not reduced.

The diocese needs an extra £88,000 per annum to break even.

But in an article in the Scottish Catholic Observer, the Bishop of Argyll and the Isles has told parishioners he is confident the deficit can be wiped by support from parishes.

The expected income of Argyll and the Isles diocese is £207,883 and expenditure for the coming year is set at £296,118, meaning a deficit for 2019 projected to be £88,235.

Bishop Brian McGee addressed the ‘dire’ state of his diocese’s finances with that aim to give ‘full transparency’ about the weekly offertory collection.

In the article the Bishop McGee spoke of a ‘perilous situation’ with budget figures for 2019, stating that it will cost £296,118 to run the diocese: ‘Our highest costs are diocesan administration; Sick and Retired Priests fund (we presently have seven), Student Priests Fund (we presently have two) and CNET (Bishops’ Conference) which pays for national commitments such as the [Interdiocesan] Tribunal, Scottish Catholic Education Service, Parliamentary and Press Offices etc.

‘We have more churches per head of population than any other diocese, which are often battered by the inclement weather and our priests have more ground to cover.’

From December 1 the diocese levy for each parish will increase, with the bishop asking each parishioner to donate an extra £1 per week to the offertory collection, if they can.

The diocese believes the measure will increase parish income and eradicate the diocesan deficit.

Bishop McGee added: ‘We felt it was essential that our parishioners were made aware of the financial situation we find ourselves in – it’s their money that goes into the collection each week and these documents will clearly outline where the money is spent.

‘We are not looking to make a profit—we are looking to break even. If everyone puts in an extra £1 then 61 pence will go to the diocese and 39 pence will stay with each parish.

‘However, since an average of 2,793 people attend Mass every Sunday, a £1 increase over and above what they already donate, would cover this.

‘The diocesan trustees, diocesan finance board and the diocesan staff have been working hard to resolve this problem. Over the past six months there has been extensive consultation with the clergy and parish finance committees.

‘Our priests in the diocese have also been very supportive of what information we are making public and they are hearing positive feedback from the lay people, so things are very hopeful.

‘Communication has been key to getting the message out there and we will continue to refresh the information our parishes receive with quarterly updates about the state of the finances in a report published on the website.

‘Most people will be unaware of where their money goes when they hand over the weekly collection but these documents clearly outline diocese spending towards God’s work, which we believe is a good thing.’

Bishop McGee, who was appointed to Argyll and the Isles Diocese in 2016, says his experience as vicar general when he served in Paisley Diocese convinced him to tackle the finances in his new position.

In January 2017 Paisley Diocese launched an innovative new campaign to try and pay off its £3 million deficit, encouraging parishioners to become ‘friends’ of various diocesan projects and donate money to help clear an annual shortfall of £300,000.

Bishop McGee added: ‘I was here when the campaign began in Paisley but I was made aware of their deficit when I was serving in the diocese as vicar general. That experience convinced me to tackle the issue of finance when I was appointed to this diocese.

‘Each diocese approaches things differently. For us we are the smallest in terms of population but we are the furthest spread. We are unique in that we have a lot of churches that are battered by the weather and we have big distances between parishes.

‘A priest may need to travel 70 or 80 miles to attend to a sick person in our diocese and there is an added burden of travel cost or things like petrol or taking the boat in order to say Mass or attend meetings.”

The diocese considered selling Bishop’s House in Oban, however, because it is the only building which the diocese owns and is still used as an office and for meetings, the option was not thought viable.

Bishop McGee added: ‘The house in Oban was mentioned because we have to think of all possibilities, however it would only plug the funding gap for a year or two and it still has a number of functions.

‘It is used by the diocese administration as an office – rent free – and for clergy meetings, so we have investigated the possibility of selling it, but we’d rather not.’