Poignant letter portrays torment of Great War’s forgotten pacifists

Robert Climie and fellow conscientious objectors Pic Peter Devlin

Want to read more?

We value our content and access to our full site is only available with a  subscription. Your subscription entitles you to 7-day-a-week access to our website, plus a full digital copy of that week’s paper to read on your pc/mac or mobile device.  In addition, your subscription includes access to digital archive copies from 2006 onwards.

Just want to read one issue? No problem you can subscribe for just one week (or longer if you wish).

Already a subscriber?


Problems logging in and require
technical support? Click here
Subscribe Now

The struggle of Scotland’s conscientious objectors who refused the call to arms in the First World War is being highlighted by a letter from an Ayrshire father to his baby daughter, written from a labour camp in Argyll.

Ayrshire postal worker Robert Climie had been a lifelong activist in the international peace movement before he was conscripted in 1916.

Exercising his right to appeal on political grounds, a tribunal hearing initially backed Robert’s case before a retired army officer, outraged at his refusal to fight, pursued the matter and saw it overturned. Like hundreds of other Scottish objectors, Robert was imprisoned at Wormwood Scrubs, before being moved to a labour camp by Loch Awe to work on forestry.

Conscientious objectors Sandy Stewart and Robert Climie, right, who met at the labour camp at Loch Awe Photograph Peter Devlin
Conscientious objectors Sandy Stewart and Robert Climie, right, who met at the labour camp at Loch Awe.
Photograph Peter Devlin

Writing from Cruachan Estate on his daughter Cathie’s first birthday, the absent father’s four-page letter says: ‘The first year of your life … will in later years be known as one of the worst years in the History of the World.’

It continues: ‘A most fearful war is raging … The World is just now divided into nations and the people of each nation believe themselves to be fighting on behalf of their own particular country … However, there are men and women who believe that all men and women are brothers and sisters. These people are known as Pacifists.’

Cathie Climie. Photograph Peter Devlin
Cathie Climie.
Photograph Peter Devlin

Historian and author Robert Duncan, whose book Objectors and Resisters chronicles the story of the peace movement from 1914-18, says Robert’s story is not unusual.

‘Between 1,400 and 1,500 Scots men were convicted for opposing the war,’ he said. ‘The conscience clause which enabled them to appeal conscription only applied to religious or moral grounds, and not the political beliefs which led so many to be involved in the international peace movement.’

As we approach the centenary of the Armistice agreement this month, Mr Duncan says the men’s story has been largely neglected. ‘The commemorations have been on the side of patriotism,’ he said. ‘The conscientious objectors remain much maligned and misunderstood. At the time, they split families and communities, but these were principled men who were prepared to face the consequences and their story should be heard.’

Actor Gary Lewis has contributed a powerful reading of the intimate correspondence which is held in Glasgow Caledonian University’s archive. It is now being shared online to help tell the forgotten story of Scotland’s pacifist movement.

Actor Gary Lewis with Robert Climie's letter detailing his opposition to WW1, written to his daughter Cathie who is pictured in the background Photograph Peter Devlin
Actor Gary Lewis with Robert Climie’s letter detailing his opposition to WW1, written to his daughter Cathie, in the background.
Photograph Peter Devlin

Glasgow Caledonian University archivist Carole McCallum says the letter was donated by the Stewart/Climie family, along with memorabilia and photographs from the pacifist movement to the university’s collection on social justice. And they have particular cause to remember Robert’s wartime legacy.

Carole says: ‘When Robert Climie was put to work in the labour camp, he befriended a fellow pacifist called Alex Stewart. The men stayed in touch, and Robert’s daughter Cathie went on to marry Alex’s son – whom she supported when he became a conscientious objector in the Second World War. It is their son who now wishes his grandfather Robert’s story to be remembered.’

She added: ‘Every time I have read Robert’s letter I have cried, and never more so than hearing Gary Lewis read it out aloud in front of our cameras. We have heard lots of people’s stories from the First World War over the past four years, and I feel this one stands out in our archives and deserved to be told in a different way.

‘I hope people will listen to Gary’s reading and think about why a child was brought up without her father because of something her parents believed in and which was against the prevailing mood at the time.’