Simplistic view of Glencoe massacre

Want to read more?

At the start of the pandemic in March we took the decision to make online access to our news free of charge by taking down our paywall. At a time where accurate information about Covid-19 was vital to our community, this was the right decision – even though it meant a drop in our income. In order to help safeguard the future of our journalism, the time has now come to reinstate our paywall, However, rest assured that access to all Covid related news will still remain free.

To access all other news will require a subscription, as it did pre-pandemic The good news is that for the whole of December we will be running a special discounted offer to get 3 months access for the price of one month. Thanks you for supporting us during this incredibly challenging time

We value our content  and access to our full site is  only available with a  subscription. Your subscription entitles you to 7-day-a-week access to our website, plus a full digital copy of that week’s paper to read on your pc/mac or mobile device In addition your subscription includes access to digital archive copies from 2006 onwards

Just want to read one issue? No problem you can subscribe for just one week (or longer if you wish)

Already a subscriber?

 

Subscribe Now

Sir,

Concerning the piece in last week’s Oban Times headlined ‘Glencoe massacre remembered 325 years on’, I should like to offer an alternative to the simplistic and inaccurate opening paragraph mentioning the ‘massacre of MacDonalds by Campbells in Glencoe‘.

The massacre was clearly a dreadful breach of Highland hospitality, brutal and cruel, but, for the sake of accuracy, the first paragraph could have read ‘massacre of MacDonalds by a detachment of regular British soldiers acting under orders given by a Scottish Secretary [John Dalrymple] and sanctioned by a Dutch King [William]’.

It is true to say there was Campbell involvement in the lead up to and during the massacre. John Campbell, Earl of Breadalbane, negotiated with clan chiefs loyal to the exiled Stuart King James to try to convince them not to hesitate in offering their required oath of allegiance to King William, rather than waiting for formal permission to be sent from James in France.

The company of regular British soldiers were commanded by Robert Campbell of Glenlyon. Glenlyon was ordered to billet his men with the MacDonalds at Glencoe and await orders.

He had no idea of the real reason for his soldiers stay at Glencoe until his orders came through from Fort William late on February 12, 1692. The order threatened to treat Glenlyon as ‘not true to King or government’ if he did not act as ordered.

Two officers refused to lead the killings and were arrested and it is thought that when the soldiers became aware of their orders, some of them helped the MacDonalds to escape by deliberately firing wide.

Such an important and tragic event in Scottish history should not be simplified to a Disneyesque view of ‘evil Campbells killed lots of MacDonalds’.

Rod Campbell,
Lossit, Benderloch.